Blog
A hospital-acquired infection can be medical malpractice in Illinois when the care team missed a step a careful provider would have taken, such as leaving a catheter in too long or not acting on a fever, and that mistake caused the infection or made it worse. Most of these claims must be filed within two years of when you knew or should have known about the injury, and no later than four years after the care.

You or someone you love went into the hospital for one problem and came out with another: an infection that meant more surgery, weeks of IV antibiotics, or a stay in intensive care. The staff called it a known risk. Sometimes that is true. On the other hand, sometimes a chart shows a catheter left in place too long, a fever charted and ignored, or a delay in starting treatment. Illinois law gives the patient, and anyone with the patient’s written authorization, the right to see and copy that chart. A Chicago medical malpractice attorney can help you learn what your records show.

When a Hospital Infection Points to Negligence

On any given day in 2023, about 1 in 38 U.S. hospital patients had at least one infection acquired during care, according to the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention (CDC). The same survey found that patients in 2023 were 27% less likely to have one than patients in 2015, and CDC reports significant progress in preventing some types of these infections.

Whether an infection is malpractice depends on two questions. The first is whether the doctors, nurses, or hospital failed to meet the standard of care. That term means the level of skill and care a reasonably careful provider would use in the same situation. The second question is whether that failure caused the infection or made it worse.

A medical expert reviewing an infection case starts with questions like these:

  • Was a central line, urinary catheter, or breathing tube kept in place, and does the chart explain why it was still needed each day?
  • Did nurses record a fever, redness, drainage, or a change in mental state, and what did anyone do about it?
  • How many hours passed between the first warning sign and the first dose of antibiotics?
  • Were lab and culture results read and acted on when they came back?
  • Was the patient sent home with an infection developing and no clear instructions?

If the answers show a missed step or a delay, the next question is whether that failure caused the infection or made it worse. Our hospital negligence lawyers can review the chart for those missed steps and delays.

What You Have to Prove in Illinois

The Illinois Supreme Court listed the three parts of a malpractice claim in Purtill v. Hess (1986). You have to prove the standard of care, a failure to meet it, and an injury that failure caused.

The court also explained that expert medical testimony is required to prove the standard and the failure, unless the negligence is so obvious, or the treatment so common, that an ordinary person would understand it from everyday experience. The court said a doctor’s conduct must be judged in light of the conditions and facilities that doctor had to work with. When those conditions matter to the case, the expert must know the accepted standards of care under similar circumstances.

The third part is causation. The defense can argue the infection would have happened even with careful treatment. Therefore, the evidence, usually including expert testimony, has to connect the missed step to the infection, or show that a delay in treatment made the harm worse.

When the Infection Itself Can Suggest Negligence

Illinois allows a patient to rely on res ipsa loquitur, Latin for “the thing speaks for itself,” in a malpractice case. Under this doctrine, a court can allow an inference of negligence from the medical result itself. A judge decides whether it applies. The judge relies on common knowledge or on expert medical testimony that the result would not ordinarily have occurred without negligence by the defendant.

The patient must also show that whatever caused the harm was under the control of the defendants being sued. That can be hard to prove in an infection case. Many infections happen even with careful care, and germs can come from many sources. In one Illinois case, a court refused to apply the doctrine to an eye infection after cataract surgery because the patient’s own experts agreed such infections can occur without negligence.

When a patient relies on this doctrine, the reviewing physician’s written report must state that negligence occurred in the course of medical treatment. The patient’s attorney, or the patient if filing without one, must also certify that reliance when filing the complaint. Even when the infection itself suggests negligence, the case still needs that written expert opinion.

The Medical Records That Matter Most

Illinois law lets a patient, or the patient’s attorney, examine and copy hospital records, including the history, bedside notes, and charts. A request for copies must be in writing and delivered to the hospital’s administrator or manager. The hospital has 30 days to provide copies of your hospital records. If it needs more time, it must explain the delay in writing within those 30 days and give a date, and it must produce the records within 60 days.

If the patient has died, the executor or administrator of the estate, or an agent named in the patient’s health care power of attorney, can request the records. If there is none, and the patient did not object in writing, a surviving spouse can request them. If there is no spouse, an adult child, parent, or adult sibling can. The relative must provide a signed Authorized Relative Certification and a certified copy of the death certificate.

For an infection claim, ask for the complete chart, including:

  • Nursing notes and vital-sign flowsheets, which show when a fever or other change was first recorded
  • Physician orders and progress notes, which show who knew what and when
  • The medication administration record, which shows exactly when each antibiotic dose was given
  • Lab and culture reports, with the times they were ordered, collected, and resulted
  • Records for every line, catheter, and drain, including when each was placed and removed
  • Operative, anesthesia, and wound-care notes for any surgical site infection
  • Discharge instructions and any follow-up calls

Request these records early, because the physician who writes the required report must first review the medical record.

Under an Illinois law on medical studies, information that hospital quality-review committees use for internal quality control is privileged, and a patient cannot obtain it or use it as evidence in a lawsuit. The Illinois Supreme Court has held that this protection is narrow. Facts staff knew before a committee review are not protected just because they were later reported to a committee, and the hospital must prove the privilege applies. The same law leaves the patient’s medical records outside that protection, so the chart is the evidence you can get.

What Public Infection Data Can and Cannot Do

Under the Hospital Report Card Act, licensed Illinois hospitals report infection measures to the Illinois Department of Public Health every quarter, and those reports are made public. The data can help you ask better questions about a hospital’s infection record.

The same law bars using that public data to establish the standard of care in a private lawsuit. A hospital’s infection rate cannot prove what your care team should have done. That proof comes from the chart and, unless the negligence is obvious to an ordinary person, a qualified medical expert.

Illinois Deadlines for Infection Claims

The deadline to sue a licensed doctor, registered nurse, or hospital in Illinois is generally two years from the earliest of three dates: when you knew about the injury or death, when you reasonably should have known about it, or when you received written notice of it. Illinois courts start this clock once you also know, or reasonably should know, that the harm may have been caused by someone’s mistake. When that happens is often disputed, so do not wait.

A statute of repose, an outer limit that applies no matter when you learned of the harm, bars most claims filed more than four years after the care that caused the injury.

Different deadlines apply in some cases, including these:

  • A patient injured before age 18 generally has up to eight years from the care at issue, but no later than the patient’s 22nd birthday. This extra time may be shorter or unavailable in claims against government hospitals and clinics.
  • If the person responsible fraudulently hid the claim, the patient has five years from discovering it.

Claims against the State of Illinois or a state university board, including a claim over care at the University of Illinois Hospital in Chicago, go to the Illinois Court of Claims. Within one year after the injury or after the claim accrues, the patient must file a written notice with the Illinois Attorney General and the Clerk of the Court of Claims. No notice is needed if the claim itself is filed within one year after it accrues. In a death case, the estate’s representative has one year from the death or from being appointed, whichever is later. Missing this notice bars the claim. The claim itself must be filed within two years after it accrues.

Claims against a county or city hospital, such as Cook County’s Stroger Hospital, follow a separate law that uses the same two-year and four-year limits. A claim over care by a federal employee, such as a doctor at a VA medical center, must first be presented in writing to the federal agency within two years after the claim accrues. If the agency denies the claim by certified or registered mail, the lawsuit must be filed within six months after that denial is mailed. The same federal rules can apply to care at many federally funded community health centers, whose staff may be treated as federal employees.

In Illinois state court, a malpractice complaint must also include an affidavit and a written report finding a reasonable and meritorious cause for the suit. In claims against hospitals, nurses, and doctors, that report must come from a physician licensed to practice medicine in all its branches. If the deadline is too close to get that report, the attorney can file an affidavit saying so with the complaint, and the report is then due within 90 days after filing.

If a hospital fails to produce records within 60 days of a request, the attorney can file an affidavit saying so, and the report is then due within 90 days after the records arrive. Failing to file the required certificate is grounds to dismiss the case, so these steps have to start early. Federal courts, including in VA cases, still require the report, but it does not have to be attached to the complaint.

Talk With a Chicago Trial Lawyer About Your Infection

At Hale Law, we prepare every case as if it will go to trial, and we can review the chart with you. If a hospital infection changed your life or took a loved one, contact Hale Law for a free, confidential consultation. The consultation carries no obligation, and we can meet you at home or in the hospital.

About the Author
Andy M. Hale is a trial attorney with over 30 years of experience in civil rights and commercial litigation matters. He also specializes in personal injury, medical malpractice, and wrongful death cases. Andy has focused his trial practice on civil rights cases.  Mr. Hale has been involved in numerous high-profile cases during his three-decade legal career.
Posted in Medical Malpractice
By Andy Hale
Partner
Hospital-Acquired Infections and Medical Malpractice Claims
A hospital-acquired infection can be medical malpractice in Illinois when the care team missed a step a careful provider would have taken, such as leaving a catheter in too long or not acting on a fever, and that mistake caused the infection or made it worse. Most of these claims must be filed within two years of when you knew or should have known about the injury, and no later than four years after the care.

You or someone you love went into the hospital for one problem and came out with another: an infection that meant more surgery, weeks of IV antibiotics, or a stay in intensive care. The staff called it a known risk. Sometimes that is true. On the other hand, sometimes a chart shows a catheter left in place too long, a fever charted and ignored, or a delay in starting treatment. Illinois law gives the patient, and anyone with the patient’s written authorization, the right to see and copy that chart. A Chicago medical malpractice attorney can help you learn what your records show.

When a Hospital Infection Points to Negligence

On any given day in 2023, about 1 in 38 U.S. hospital patients had at least one infection acquired during care, according to the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention (CDC). The same survey found that patients in 2023 were 27% less likely to have one than patients in 2015, and CDC reports significant progress in preventing some types of these infections.

Whether an infection is malpractice depends on two questions. The first is whether the doctors, nurses, or hospital failed to meet the standard of care. That term means the level of skill and care a reasonably careful provider would use in the same situation. The second question is whether that failure caused the infection or made it worse.

A medical expert reviewing an infection case starts with questions like these:

  • Was a central line, urinary catheter, or breathing tube kept in place, and does the chart explain why it was still needed each day?
  • Did nurses record a fever, redness, drainage, or a change in mental state, and what did anyone do about it?
  • How many hours passed between the first warning sign and the first dose of antibiotics?
  • Were lab and culture results read and acted on when they came back?
  • Was the patient sent home with an infection developing and no clear instructions?

If the answers show a missed step or a delay, the next question is whether that failure caused the infection or made it worse. Our hospital negligence lawyers can review the chart for those missed steps and delays.

What You Have to Prove in Illinois

The Illinois Supreme Court listed the three parts of a malpractice claim in Purtill v. Hess (1986). You have to prove the standard of care, a failure to meet it, and an injury that failure caused.

The court also explained that expert medical testimony is required to prove the standard and the failure, unless the negligence is so obvious, or the treatment so common, that an ordinary person would understand it from everyday experience. The court said a doctor’s conduct must be judged in light of the conditions and facilities that doctor had to work with. When those conditions matter to the case, the expert must know the accepted standards of care under similar circumstances.

The third part is causation. The defense can argue the infection would have happened even with careful treatment. Therefore, the evidence, usually including expert testimony, has to connect the missed step to the infection, or show that a delay in treatment made the harm worse.

When the Infection Itself Can Suggest Negligence

Illinois allows a patient to rely on res ipsa loquitur, Latin for “the thing speaks for itself,” in a malpractice case. Under this doctrine, a court can allow an inference of negligence from the medical result itself. A judge decides whether it applies. The judge relies on common knowledge or on expert medical testimony that the result would not ordinarily have occurred without negligence by the defendant.

The patient must also show that whatever caused the harm was under the control of the defendants being sued. That can be hard to prove in an infection case. Many infections happen even with careful care, and germs can come from many sources. In one Illinois case, a court refused to apply the doctrine to an eye infection after cataract surgery because the patient’s own experts agreed such infections can occur without negligence.

When a patient relies on this doctrine, the reviewing physician’s written report must state that negligence occurred in the course of medical treatment. The patient’s attorney, or the patient if filing without one, must also certify that reliance when filing the complaint. Even when the infection itself suggests negligence, the case still needs that written expert opinion.

The Medical Records That Matter Most

Illinois law lets a patient, or the patient’s attorney, examine and copy hospital records, including the history, bedside notes, and charts. A request for copies must be in writing and delivered to the hospital’s administrator or manager. The hospital has 30 days to provide copies of your hospital records. If it needs more time, it must explain the delay in writing within those 30 days and give a date, and it must produce the records within 60 days.

If the patient has died, the executor or administrator of the estate, or an agent named in the patient’s health care power of attorney, can request the records. If there is none, and the patient did not object in writing, a surviving spouse can request them. If there is no spouse, an adult child, parent, or adult sibling can. The relative must provide a signed Authorized Relative Certification and a certified copy of the death certificate.

For an infection claim, ask for the complete chart, including:

  • Nursing notes and vital-sign flowsheets, which show when a fever or other change was first recorded
  • Physician orders and progress notes, which show who knew what and when
  • The medication administration record, which shows exactly when each antibiotic dose was given
  • Lab and culture reports, with the times they were ordered, collected, and resulted
  • Records for every line, catheter, and drain, including when each was placed and removed
  • Operative, anesthesia, and wound-care notes for any surgical site infection
  • Discharge instructions and any follow-up calls

Request these records early, because the physician who writes the required report must first review the medical record.

Under an Illinois law on medical studies, information that hospital quality-review committees use for internal quality control is privileged, and a patient cannot obtain it or use it as evidence in a lawsuit. The Illinois Supreme Court has held that this protection is narrow. Facts staff knew before a committee review are not protected just because they were later reported to a committee, and the hospital must prove the privilege applies. The same law leaves the patient’s medical records outside that protection, so the chart is the evidence you can get.

What Public Infection Data Can and Cannot Do

Under the Hospital Report Card Act, licensed Illinois hospitals report infection measures to the Illinois Department of Public Health every quarter, and those reports are made public. The data can help you ask better questions about a hospital’s infection record.

The same law bars using that public data to establish the standard of care in a private lawsuit. A hospital’s infection rate cannot prove what your care team should have done. That proof comes from the chart and, unless the negligence is obvious to an ordinary person, a qualified medical expert.

Illinois Deadlines for Infection Claims

The deadline to sue a licensed doctor, registered nurse, or hospital in Illinois is generally two years from the earliest of three dates: when you knew about the injury or death, when you reasonably should have known about it, or when you received written notice of it. Illinois courts start this clock once you also know, or reasonably should know, that the harm may have been caused by someone’s mistake. When that happens is often disputed, so do not wait.

A statute of repose, an outer limit that applies no matter when you learned of the harm, bars most claims filed more than four years after the care that caused the injury.

Different deadlines apply in some cases, including these:

  • A patient injured before age 18 generally has up to eight years from the care at issue, but no later than the patient’s 22nd birthday. This extra time may be shorter or unavailable in claims against government hospitals and clinics.
  • If the person responsible fraudulently hid the claim, the patient has five years from discovering it.

Claims against the State of Illinois or a state university board, including a claim over care at the University of Illinois Hospital in Chicago, go to the Illinois Court of Claims. Within one year after the injury or after the claim accrues, the patient must file a written notice with the Illinois Attorney General and the Clerk of the Court of Claims. No notice is needed if the claim itself is filed within one year after it accrues. In a death case, the estate’s representative has one year from the death or from being appointed, whichever is later. Missing this notice bars the claim. The claim itself must be filed within two years after it accrues.

Claims against a county or city hospital, such as Cook County’s Stroger Hospital, follow a separate law that uses the same two-year and four-year limits. A claim over care by a federal employee, such as a doctor at a VA medical center, must first be presented in writing to the federal agency within two years after the claim accrues. If the agency denies the claim by certified or registered mail, the lawsuit must be filed within six months after that denial is mailed. The same federal rules can apply to care at many federally funded community health centers, whose staff may be treated as federal employees.

In Illinois state court, a malpractice complaint must also include an affidavit and a written report finding a reasonable and meritorious cause for the suit. In claims against hospitals, nurses, and doctors, that report must come from a physician licensed to practice medicine in all its branches. If the deadline is too close to get that report, the attorney can file an affidavit saying so with the complaint, and the report is then due within 90 days after filing.

If a hospital fails to produce records within 60 days of a request, the attorney can file an affidavit saying so, and the report is then due within 90 days after the records arrive. Failing to file the required certificate is grounds to dismiss the case, so these steps have to start early. Federal courts, including in VA cases, still require the report, but it does not have to be attached to the complaint.

Talk With a Chicago Trial Lawyer About Your Infection

At Hale Law, we prepare every case as if it will go to trial, and we can review the chart with you. If a hospital infection changed your life or took a loved one, contact Hale Law for a free, confidential consultation. The consultation carries no obligation, and we can meet you at home or in the hospital.

About the Author
Andy M. Hale is a trial attorney with over 30 years of experience in civil rights and commercial litigation matters. He also specializes in personal injury, medical malpractice, and wrongful death cases. Andy has focused his trial practice on civil rights cases.  Mr. Hale has been involved in numerous high-profile cases during his three-decade legal career.
Website developed in accordance with Web Content Accessibility Guidelines 2.2.
If you encounter any issues while using this site, please contact us: 312.870.6902